Bore Your Opponent Til Resignation!

Hey guys (and gals…should we eventually add one to our stereotypically male membership), Ben here. At our last Tallahassee Chess Club meeting I playfully ribbed Steve for prioritizing his job and other life responsibilities ahead of keeping this blog up to date by the minute. Then he told me to step up and contribute. Be careful what you wish for folks, lesson learned. In all truth I’m pumped to get the opportunity to bring something to the table whenever I can and I hope that you all find some interest in my mostly chess related ramblings too.

Now it just so happened that this past Saturday I was at Black Dog Cafe on Lake Ella (because I forgot to help out at the Scholastic Tourney, sorry Steve my loss) with the rest my fellow Tallahassee coffee house players.  As usual Eric and I were combining some very dubious blitz play with some very no holds bar trash-talk, all in good humor. So if you feel like refuting speculative sacrifices whilst facing a barrage of schoolyard insults come on down. DISCLAIMER: Honestly speaking do not be scared off as I am perhaps the only one partaking in such adolescent behaviour, in fact I believe we have one of the most welcoming clubs in town. As it happened one of Eric’s favorite prods when and if he loses, especially when he runs low on time and flags, is that I won by “boring him to death” hence the title of my post. Now as we are playing wild blitz game after wild blitz game I can assure you all this is far from the case, which makes the joke even funnier, but it did get me thinking about when and if I had ever done that…The answer is yes, once, and I’d like to present the game to you.

There are games I somewhat recall and games I will always remember and this is one I was and am particularly proud of. It was at the World Open in Philly back in 2009. Don’t let the name fool you I played in the U1600 section. I did a quick search to find that my rating was 1515 and it was my 8th ever event, my first tournament being in 2007 at the Miami Open. I went 6/9, losing two of my three losses quite unforced and pathetically so I can tell you my play was as inconsistent as ever. In my mind this is every chessplayer’s worst enemy, we can all find brilliant moves but to avoid bad ones move after move and game after game is the true mark of a strong player.

Here I include a link to the game that you can open up in another window and play through along with my annotations (pardon its’ ridiculous length):   [editor: I shortened the link using]

Please keep in mind that the following game was played by a couple of 1500s and I’m sure it is far from perfect. I am also sure that running an engine on the moves will produce a forest of better alternative moves but, as will always be the rule for most if not all of my past and future analysis, I choose not to consult the engine, at least not before mulling it over myself. I also do not currently own a Fritz or Houdini, etc so I usually harass Steve into consulting the silicone chess gods for me. Giddy up, here she goes!

Round 6: Ben Silva (1515) vs Stephen Crookston (1570)

1. d4 Nf6 2. Nf3 g6 3. Bg5 Bg7 4. e3 O-O 5. Nbd2

The Torre, admittedly my opening knowledge is like a shallow puddle, lacking breadth and depth, so you could say that Phase 1 of “Operation Boredom” begins with my choice of the opening. I simply want something non-committal, flexible, solid and closed.

After 5. Nbd2

After 5. Nbd2

5…d6 6. Bc4 Nbd7 7. O-O c6 8. c3 b5 9. Bb3 Bb7 10. Re1 Qc7 11. Nf1

I actually quite like Black’s setup as my opponent seems properly positioned to open up the game. Having said this I also like my own position for the reasons I mentioned earlier. One aspect of my early chess successes that I wish to get back to was the ability to play opossum in the early middle game, prompting my opponent to overextend and/or incorrectly commit his pawns. Thus begins Phase 2.

position after 11. Nf1

After 11. Nf1

11…e5 12. Ng3 c5 13. Rc1 c4 14. Bc2 Rfe8 15. e4 h6 16. Be3 Rad8 17. d5 a5 18. h3 Rc8 19. Kf1 Nc5 20. Qe2 Ba6 21. Kg1

What may seem like indecisive piece shuffling has actually been a conscious effort to entice Black’s  pawns to be pushed forward, especially on the queenside. Specifically I recall playing this Kf1 followed by Qe2 idea with the point to provoke Black’s a5 and Ba6. Similarly I was happy to leave my bishop on b3 as long as possible until the c4 push which must have also been played in dual response to Rc1 (as well as closing in the Bishop).

Position after 21. Kg1

After 21. Kg1

21…Nfd7 22. Qd2 Kh7 23. Nh2 Nf6 24. f4

After semi-tying up his bad bishop and king to the defense of h6 I finally open the game a little, but only after I feel completely ready and safe, and on my own terms. This is key. Perhaps it seems that Black could’ve opened the game himself earlier whenever he chose but things were never as easy as they might appear on first glance. Over the board, it was my belief that I had successfully, either directly or indirectly, discouraged this opening of the game from happening. My beliefs where reinforced when after the game my opponent admitted to me that he felt I had repeatedly kept him from doing so.

24…Ng8 25. Nf3 f6 26. fxe5 fxe5 27. Rf1 Rf8 28. Nh2 Rcd8 29. Ng4 Bc8

Phase 2 complete (excuse my cheesiness but I think I will stick with this “Phase” whatever talk), my opponent’s pawns look sufficiently vulnerable and so only then, when I feel like I am only playing for two results, I begin to trade off the heavy pieces.

Position after 29. ... Bc8

After 29. … Bc8

30. Rxf8 Rxf8 31. Nh2 Nd7 32. Rf1 Qd8 33. Rxf8 Qxf8 34. Qf2 Qe7 35. Nf3 Ndf6 36. Bb6

This move has long time been in preparation which made it all the more satisfying to get to play.

36…a4 37. Ba5 Qb7 38. Qb6 Qxb6+ 39. Bxb6

This mark’s the end of the 3rd act of Boredom. I will tell you now I most certainly wanted my opponent to think I was steering us to a quiet draw devoid of pieces and no access points for either kings.

After 39. Bxb6

After 39. Bxb6

39…Bf8 40. Nd2 Kg7 41. Kf2 Nd7 42. Ba5 Kf7 43. Nb1 Nc5 44. Bb4 Bd7?

Probably a crucial mistake, now I have almost everything I need for a win out of the position and everything has gone even better than planned. Understandably my opponent perhaps rationalized allowing the capture of the knight on general principles such as his having the only bishop pair in the endgame or obtaining a pawn majority on the queenside with thoughts to push b4 however the reality of the situation is that with my two knights who have seemingly been bumbling about I can defend the b4 push by keeping pressure on c4 and simultaneoulsy my knights in cooperation with each other and my king can move to resolve the kingside. I still enjoy seeing the next few moves as the knights seem like intertwining cobras in my imagination.

45. Bxc5 dxc5 46. Nd2 Bd6 47. Ngf1 h5 48. Ne3 Kf6 49. Nf3 Nh6 50. Kg3 Nf7 51. Kh4 Bc8 52. g4 hxg4 53. Nxg4+ Bxg4??

The final and critical mistake, like taking a sledgehammer to the keystone in Black’s arch. His position is now completely lost. Perhaps you have already seen the crux of my grand scheme. As far back as 19. Kf1 and in some sense even further the idea, which became set in stone on move 36. Ba6, has been to eat all of Black’s queenside pawns without giving anything in return. Now that Black’s lightsquare bishop has left the board, and both his king and knight are far out of play, how will the a4-b5-c4 pawn chain be defended?

Position after 53. ...  Bxg4??

After 53. … Bxg4??

54. Kxg4 Nh6+ 55. Kg3 g5 56. Nd2!

Finally it begins to dawn on Black, just how helpless his circumstances are. The rest is as they say “a matter of technique”.

56… Kg6 57. Nb1 Nf7 58. Na3 b4 59. Nxc4 Bc7 60. cxb4 cxb4 61. Bxa4 Nd6?

Seemingly a blunder but probably a failed last ditch attempt at tactics brought on by time pressure and the hopelessness of the situation. Although I haven’t yet mentioned time, we played with the classical controls of 2hrs followed by an additional hour after move 40 and 15 minutes after move 60, not to mention the increment of 30 seconds I believe. So as you can see we made all of the time controls and I tell you we used all of our time. Indeed I made sure to take all my time which is of course another key element, perhaps most important, when attempting to bore your opponent to death. I gotta say I really enjoyed playing these last moves that follow, the whole king walk to h5, Bishop maneuver to Bg6, and Knight jumps to the eventual d3 are perhaps the most harmonious moves I have ever made. The resulting position in which Black resigns is the position I will always recall when I think of the term zugzwang (perhaps one could even say Black has been in zugzwang for some time now).

62. Nxe5+ Kg7 63. Kf3 Nb7 64. Nc4 Nd6 65. b3 Nf7 66. Kg4 Kf6 67. Kh5 Bf4 68. Be8 Nd6 69. Bg6

I should probably include a side-line for those who might think this endgame could be holdable with the opposite colored bishops after the exchange of knights: 69…Nxc4 70. bxc4 Ke5 71. c5 Kd4 72. c6 Kc3 73. Kg4 Kb2 74. Bf7! Bd6 75. Kxg5 Kxa2? 76. c7! Bxc7 77. d6+ stopping Black’s b4 pawn from promoting and winning the Black bishop.

After 69. Bg6

After 69. Bg6

69…Ke7 70. Nb2 Bd2 71. Nd3 1-0

There is no stopping my passed pawns without further loss of material and so Black resigns.

Please feel free to leave a comment on the post or game. Hope you enjoyed it.

6 thoughts on “Bore Your Opponent Til Resignation!

    • I guess normally I might, but since my name is both at the beginning of the post and again at the start of the annotations I thought it would be redundant. Btw my (blog) author name is “e4a6”, which is at the top of the post. As “for a win is a win…”, I always thought of that as something to console one’s self when the win was ugly. Not so sure that applies here but then “beauty is in the eye of the beholder”. -Ben


  1. I think this is among the most significant info for me. And i am glad reading your article. But want to remark on some general things, The website style is wonderful, the articles is really great D. Good job, cheers fddbecddcgfe


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s